The Ultimate Adults-Only Dessert Restaurant in Key West

Signature rimmed drinks. Award-winning desserts. Nights meant to linger. 

Key West is made for evenings like this.

After the legendary sunset at Mallory Square and dinner in Old Town, the best nights don’t end-they transition. Better Than Sex is where the island slows down just long enough to truly enjoy it.

Located just one block off Duval Street, our flagship dessert restaurant offers an intimate escape from the crowds. It is the perfect destination for date night, celebrations, and anyone seeking a sophisticated late-night spot.

It’s the kind of ending you remember long after the vacation is over.

Reserve View Menu

Award-winning Indulgence Near Duval Street

Tucked away in the heart of historic Old Town Key West, Better Than Sex is an adults-only dessert experience where chocolate drips, craft cocktails sparkle, and island nights linger long after the last bite.

Since opening our doors in 2008, we have been voted “Best Desserts” ten years in a row by the local Bubba Awards.

Our speakeasy-style dining room features low lighting, red velvet curtains, and an atmosphere explicitly designed for connection and celebration. 

Plan Your Key West Evening

Our intimate space only has 20 tables, designed for couples and small parties up to 4 guests.

Because of our limited seating and high demand for celebrations and late-night desserts, reservations are suggested. 

We are conveniently located at 926 Simonton Street, offering easy walk-up access from all major Old Town Key West hotels, bed and breakfasts, and Duval Street. 

Socialize with Us

@betterthansexdesserts

Our Mission

we exist to make nights worth talking about